Lesson 4 of 11

Bad-luck mitigation: same average, different curve

Two 1/1,088 drops from Vardorvis, two very different luck curves.

Same average, different curve

Switch to “Got it by now” to compare the cumulative curves.

Executioner's axe head
half by 754
average 1,088
9 in 10 by 2,505
Ultor vestige
half by 970
average 1,088
9 in 10 by 1,929
KillsExecutioner's axe headUltor vestige
Average1,0881,088
Median754970
Lucky 10% by115401
90% by2,5051,929
99% by5,0093,046
Still dry at 3× the rate4.97%0.62%

Vardorvis drops two items listed at 1/1,088: the Executioner's axe head and the Ultor vestige. Same rate, same average. They do not feel the same at all.

The axe head is one plain roll. The vestige needs 3 hidden hits of 1/362.67. The first two hits give you gold rings; the third gives the vestige.

So you cannot get a vestige on kill 1 or 2, and very early vestiges are rare: the lucky 10% need 401 kills instead of 115. In return the dry tail shrinks. At three times the rate, 4.97% of players still lack the axe head, but only 0.62% lack the vestige.

Same average, narrower spread. Fewer spoons, far fewer horror stories.

Other items with this kind of rule on the site include the Magus vestige (Duke Sucellus), the Venator vestige (The Leviathan), the Bellator vestige (The Whisperer), the Hydra's heart (Alchemical Hydra), the Hydra's fang (Alchemical Hydra) and the Dark totem middle (Skotizo).

See it on a real boss

FAQ

Quick questions

What is bad-luck mitigation in OSRS?

A rule that makes very long dry streaks rarer. For the Desert Treasure II vestiges, the drop needs several hidden lucky hits, so one lucky roll is not enough and one unlucky stretch hurts less.

Does bad-luck mitigation change the drop rate?

Not the average. The Ultor vestige still takes 1,088 kills on average, the same as the Executioner's axe head. It changes the shape: the median moves from 754 to 970 kills.

How many players go very dry on a vestige?

At three times the rate, 4.97% of players are still waiting for the Executioner's axe head, but only 0.62% for the Ultor vestige.