Lesson 9 of 11
Four kinds of dry protection
Same average, four very different luck curves. A million players for each.
Four drops can all take the same number of kills on average and still feel nothing alike. The widget gives each one the same average, plays it out for 1,000,000 players, and draws when they get it. Pick a system in the legend to see its markers.
1. A regular drop
The same chance every kill. Each kill, the same share of the players still waiting get it, so the curve starts high and slides down for a long time. That long slide is the dry tail: the unluckiest 1% need more than four times the average.
2. A rate that improves while you are dry
This is how the quartz from the Desert Treasure II bosses works before your first one. The rate starts a little worse than the average and gets better with every dry kill, until it reaches a floor. Early spoons still happen, but the curve cuts off much sooner, so nobody goes as dry.
3. Three hidden hits
The vestiges need three hits of a rarer roll before they drop. Nobody gets one on kill one or two, very few get one early, and the very dry finishes become rarer too. Everyone ends up closer to the middle.
4. A guarantee at a set kill
A flat rate until a fixed kill count, then a certain drop, like Vorkath's head. Look for the tall spike in the chart: a large group of players reach the cap without any luck and all get it on that exact kill. It is the only system here whose halfway point sits after its average.
Same average, four different stories. The average never tells you how dry you can go.
The idea of comparing these four systems at the same average comes from GamecubeJona's video on how Jagex solved the drop-rate problem, which is well worth a watch. The simulation and the words here are our own.
See it on a real boss
FAQ
Quick questions
What is dry protection in OSRS?
Any rule that makes very long dry streaks less likely than on a plain drop. OSRS uses a few: rates that improve while you are dry, items that need several hidden hits, and drops that are guaranteed by a set kill count.
How does the DT2 quartz rate work?
Before your first quartz, the rate starts at 1/200 and gets half a kill better for every dry kill, down to 1/50 after 300 kills. That works out to about 1/135 on average, and nobody goes as dry as on a plain 1/135 drop.
Is Vorkath's head guaranteed?
Yes, Vorkath's head drops by your 50th kill if it has not dropped before. The widget shows the same idea at a larger scale: a flat rate until a set kill count, then a certain drop, which piles many players onto that exact kill.
Which kind of protection is best?
It depends on what you value. The dynamic rate keeps the chance of an early spoon and still cuts the dry tail. Hit counters remove both the early spoons and the worst droughts. A guarantee caps the worst case, but many players only get the drop at the cap.